Outdoor restaurant dining, larger religious services and all retail stores are on track to be allowed again in Alameda County at the end of next week, under proposed updates to the COVID-19 shelter order unveiled by the county's health officer on Friday.
In response, Pleasanton city officials -- who'd advocated for the Tri-Valley to reopen sooner due to lower infection numbers locally -- agreed to close Main Street to vehicular traffic on weekends starting next Friday afternoon (June 19) to give restaurants and shops more room to operate outdoors.
"We are pleased to hear Alameda County Public Health Department has accelerated the reopening of some local businesses next Friday, including indoor and outdoor retail and outdoor dining," Pleasanton City Manager Nelson Fialho told the Weekly.
"Having this announcement now, will give our businesses some time to plan and prepare to open on June 19," Fialho added. "At the same time, it’s up to all of us to maintain safety standards locally through social distancing and the necessary use of face masks while in public. I’m confident Pleasanton is up to the challenge."
In announcing the new health order, effective next Friday, Alameda County health officer Dr. Erica Pan cited stabilizing conditions in recent weeks but encouraged residents to exercise caution and still adhere to social distancing and personal hygiene recommendations.
"The indicators we monitor to determine if we should continue moving forward through reopening are stable or improving," Pan said in a statement on Friday.
"We will continue to have more cases, but the steady increase in hospitalizations and the steep increase in the case rate we were seeing in late May has slowed and the hospitalizations have stabilized. We are also making significant progress in expanding and improving the efficiency of our contact tracing teams," Pan added.
The new order issued by ACPHD comes one week after the three Tri-Valley mayors co-signed a letter calling on Pan to take a subregional approach to the county regulations and reopen the Tri-Valley because of low coronavirus case rates in three cities and more expedited reopenings for nearby San Ramon and Danville.
The mayors also pointed to the collaboration among the three cities, Stanford-ValleyCare and the Alameda County Fairgrounds to operate a regional COVID-19 testing site open to residents of Pleasanton, Dublin and Livermore with no out-of-pocket cost nor appointment. City officials announced late last week that the fairgrounds testing center would be extended through July 10 -- 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. weekdays for adults and kids 10 years old and up.
Pan formally denied the mayors' request on Friday afternoon in a response letter that cited her department's new order allowing more reopenings countywide in the week ahead.
"Our responsibility as a Health Department is to the whole county, and we can’t risk losing ground we’ve gained against COVID-19 by introducing regional complexity at this time. We’ve heard you and others in the community and think our modified reopening plan addresses some of the concerns raised and keeps us on the road to safe reopening," Pan wrote in the response letter to mayors David Haubert (Dublin), Jerry Thorne (Pleasanton) and John Marchand (Livermore).
Haubert expressed support for the latest health order and said he thought the Tri-Valley mayors' letter played a key role in the more expedited reopenings.
"I’m pleased that Dr. Pan listened to the Mayors of the Tri Valley and I’m thankful to Supervisor Haggerty for also supporting our request," Haubert told the Weekly on Friday evening.
ACPHD reported as of Sunday there were 4,320 confirmed COVID-19 cases and 112 deaths among county residents. The Tri-Valley had recorded 67 cases in Pleasanton, 60 in Livermore and 32 in Dublin -- plus 56 at the Santa Rita Jail in Dublin, which is kept in a separate category.
That represented upticks of three cases in Pleasanton, three in Livermore and four in Dublin compared to one week earlier. (Countywide increases were 515 positive tests and 11 deaths during that weeklong period.)
The revised Alameda County health order will focus on increased personal and economic activities in group settings with safety protections in place -- outdoor dining at restaurants, indoor and outdoor retail, religious services, outdoor fitness classes and outdoor museums.
Pan said her department also expects to loosen restrictions in two- to four-week increments under its reopening plan that outlines phasing for the potential future return of all activities.
Retail and outdoor dining will be authorized to reopen at reduced capacity to ensure physical distancing and safety plans must be implemented, in alignment with the state's guidance. Pan "strongly recommended" those businesses continue to focus primarily on pickup and delivery options to limit lines and crowds.
Limited religious services will be allowed to resume too, for up to 100 people or less than 25% of building capacity, whichever is lower. Pan encouraged faith groups to continue virtual services (especially for high-risk congregants) and limit attendance to 25 people and provide services outdoors.
"We’re balancing the economic and spiritual health of our community with public health," Supervisor Nate Miley, whose district includes Pleasanton, said in a statement. "These openings, including the services industries, may disproportionately affect our already burdened communities of color, and we will need to be mindful of protecting everyone’s health while we’re out and about."
"I’m glad to see that we can take this step forward as a county,” added Supervisor Scott Haggerty, whose district includes Livermore and Dublin.
"It’s important to have parity across our small and large businesses, as well as across the region. The health of Alameda County residents is paramount and I’m confident that our restaurants, retailers and faith communities will prioritize the safety of their staff, customers and community," Haggerty added.
To support business reopenings in Pleasanton, city officials have signed off on the Pleasanton Downtown Association's proposal to close Main Street to vehicles for eight successive weekends starting on Father's Day weekend.
The closure will include the length of Main Street from Bernal Avenue to Del Valle Parkway, with openings for cross/through traffic at St. John/Ray streets and Rose Avenue/Neal Street.
It will start at about 2 p.m. on Fridays and continue through about 10 p.m. Sundays -- operational from 4 p.m. Fridays to 8 p.m. Sundays, with two hours on either end for setup and breakdown.
"During this street closure, restaurants, retailers and other downtown merchants will be allowed to expand their outdoor footprint to serve customers, following industry guidance and other applicable standards set out by the County and State," Fialho wrote in his letter to the PDA.
Downtown businesses that extend outdoors onto Main Street can extend 15 feet into the street but must leave current sidewalk clear. The middle 15 feet of Main Street will remain clear for emergency vehicle access and social distancing for pedestrians.
To expand into the public right-of-way, a business must provide the city with "a simple site plan." Restaurants can pursue extending their alcohol service by applying with the state for a temporary catering authorization.
The city and PDA will work to identify curbside pickup spots for retail on side streets as well as parking and safety protocols. They will also evaluate the street closure on a weekly basis, according to Fialho.
For the county's part, Pan reminded all businesses that operate "must complete the Site-Specific Protection Plan template and implement risk assessment and individual control measures, physical distancing, disinfecting and cleaning protocols, and employee training to prevent the spread of COVID-19."
She advised employers to implement COVID-19 health screenings before work and employees to complete self-assessments. She also encouraged residents to wear face coverings, including while protesting -- and if you protested, get tested for COVID-19.
"Next week's action to allow additional activities outside of the home relies heavily on all of us continuing the consistent use of face coverings, maintaining physical distancing, and practicing good hand hygiene," said Colleen Chawla, director of the Alameda County Health Care Services Agency. "These measures ensure that we are not only protecting ourselves and our families, but also the frontline workers in the businesses we will enjoy."
Comments
Birdland
on Jun 12, 2020 at 10:38 pm
on Jun 12, 2020 at 10:38 pm
Great news! Excited to get out and enjoy our Downtown! Thank you to Alameda County for being mindful about reopening and Pleasanton for closing Main Street. I hope everyone continues to wear face masks and is thoughtful about social distancing. Yay - fantastic!
Highland Oaks
on Jun 13, 2020 at 1:12 pm
on Jun 13, 2020 at 1:12 pm
Well, I really can't bring myself to 'thank' Alameda County and Dr Pan as I think she is a tyrant and imposing outrageous measures on us. How will Pleasanton conform to her new 30 foot requirement for mask wearing or has everyone just done a collective 'eye roll' at that one and summarily ignored her. Not a great way to get us to comply. Perhaps she should look to our governor. Even he realized people have their limits. Question: how do you get rid of your Health Director?
Pleasanton Heights
on Jun 13, 2020 at 4:49 pm
on Jun 13, 2020 at 4:49 pm
Fantastic, this sounds like a good start! Hopefully there will be “ No Pets” allowed during these times when restaurants start to reopen on Main St. Lets keep the streets clean and free of urine, poop and germs !!
Birdland
on Jun 13, 2020 at 10:09 pm
on Jun 13, 2020 at 10:09 pm
If only downtown restaurants had waited a week to legally reopen for outdoor dining, they would have had more room to do so responsibly. Instead, they defied county mandate and are already cramming customers into the small, crowded, and therefore risky, spaces they have available. How disappointing.
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 14, 2020 at 7:14 am
on Jun 14, 2020 at 7:14 am
Elle,
What would you do if your family's livelihood was being eroded by someone who has no stake in the loss and isn't footing the mounting bills adding up? Additionally, other counties are opening and yours isn't.....not because the data doesn't support it, just because you have a rogue interim health director that says so....one you didn't elect, have no ability to challenge or remove.
This is a country of doers, not passive victims.
another community
on Jun 14, 2020 at 8:45 am
on Jun 14, 2020 at 8:45 am
Office-based businesses deserve to open too, subject to applicable guidelines. Presently, Dr. Pan gets to decide which businesses operate based on her personal opinion of how ‘essential’ our work is. Restore the Fourteenth Amendment!
Livermore
on Jun 14, 2020 at 9:42 pm
on Jun 14, 2020 at 9:42 pm
What about the mobility impaired and the physically disabled people? Where do you expect them to park and still have equal access to dining out in downtown Pleasanton?
Old Towne
on Jun 15, 2020 at 9:38 am
on Jun 15, 2020 at 9:38 am
I think every business in Pleasanton should open now. The Alameda Health Department has no clue on what they are doing.
Birdland
on Jun 15, 2020 at 12:21 pm
on Jun 15, 2020 at 12:21 pm
Elle, the place I went to was very well spaced out and amazing about masks and cleaning. It was just taking food to go and then eating on their patio. Maybe blame the customers, not the restaurant. These poor people are losing their livelihood and their businesses. If you're not ready, that's fine too.
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 15, 2020 at 1:35 pm
on Jun 15, 2020 at 1:35 pm
Cyndy,
As described access is equal, it may not be mobility enhanced, but correct me if I'm wrong - if you're closing off the main streets there would have to be enough handicap parking at the perimeter of downtown, but not "inside" that perimeter. I see it no different than a mall. The handicap spaces are located near the mall entrance, but there is no closer parking inside the mall.
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 15, 2020 at 8:13 pm
on Jun 15, 2020 at 8:13 pm
Ok, spreading dinning into the streets of Pleasanton allowed by the Alameda County Health Department.
How does this allowance coexist with the same Alameda County Health Department for food safety. Food safety inspectors are now inspecting into the streets of Pleasanton?
Will the expansion of the dining area also expand the dinning area for the rats and cockroaches?
Castlewood
on Jun 15, 2020 at 9:10 pm
on Jun 15, 2020 at 9:10 pm
Ron:
what about us that live downtonw on Main Street and walk our dogs every day -do we have to stop because you don't want a cute adorable dog walking by? I will keep alking my dog and pick up his poop!
Ruby Hill
on Jun 16, 2020 at 12:25 am
on Jun 16, 2020 at 12:25 am
Nobody here wears a mask or even tries to social distance. I’m sure with all the openings it will be business as usual. Everyone’s forgot we are still in a pandemic. I expect to see a rise in the number of cases.
Downtown
on Jun 17, 2020 at 6:06 pm
on Jun 17, 2020 at 6:06 pm
If you seen the news or checked on social media you know that the people of Pleasanton will not be wearing masks to enjoy some gool ol fine dining. Try counting the number of Pleasanton residents that actually have a mask on outside. I can count 10 people walking on the sidewalk right now, passing each other in groups without a mask. There is nothing better than the ones with the mask around their chin lol.
Now the decent people that are out just following the Alameda county mandate by wearing a mask will be forced to confront the jerks who refuse to wear mask and walking past us in groups.
Obviously they are more important than the rest of us and our health does not matter. Instead of being a friendly neighbor and just wearing a mask so we can all enjoy downtown or a simple walk, we are being told to stay inside if we don't like it.
Unfortunately more residents of Pleasanton are going to end up getting sick. Most of the people that eat downtown are older so I hope that they stay safe. We all know thats the age group with the most to be worried about. Our gross white privilege will not protect us from Covid19. Have a great summer!
Sincerely,
Karen, wife of Darren
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 17, 2020 at 6:13 pm
on Jun 17, 2020 at 6:13 pm
Alameda County needs to end the shutdown and reopen the county to, at least, the same stage as Los Angeles County. As of June 17, our rates for infections, hospitalizations, and deaths are better than Los Angeles County. Alameda County has 129 hospital cases (2 in the Tri-Valley) with a total number of beds of 2,929, meaning a bit more than 4% of the beds have someone with Covid. By comparison, Los Angeles County has 23% of their hospital beds with someone with Covid. While any death is a terrible thing, the deaths in Alameda County have totaled 112, or 2.59% of the Covid Cases. Los Angeles County by comparison has a rate of 3.97% fatality rate. Looking at the percent of known people infected with Covid it is 0.26% of the total Alameda County population. Los Angeles County is 0.72%. Deaths as a percent of the total population is 0.007% for Alameda County and 0.029% for Los Angeles County. (All numbers are from covid19.ca.gov, ac-hcsa.maps.arcgis.com, and dashboard.publichealth.lacounty.gov. Percentages are simple divisions of the numbers from these sites).
The only areas that Alameda County falls behind Los Angeles County are in testing (140 versus 220/100K) and in Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) where Alameda County lags significantly behind Los Angeles County. Both areas can be addressed and corrected by the county, but even so, they are no reason to keep the county closed.
Alameda County does not report death by age group if a group has less than ten people in it. Of the 112 deaths, only 2 were persons of 50 or less (112 total deaths - reported deaths for other age groups). Yet the 50 or less age group accounts for 3,062 of all Covid cases (70.83%) for a death rate of 0.065%. Certainly, we can reopen for those that are 50 or younger. As we go up in age the death rate climbs rapidly (51-60 - 2.11%, 61-70 - 4.21%, 71-80 - 14.46%, 81+ - 24.44%) so it would make sense to encourage those over 80 and perhaps over 70 to stay at home for longer. Having said that, my Mother-in-Law is 94 and not in particularly good health and she has been confined to her room at her assisted living facility with no visitors since late February-early March. She doesn't have years to make up for the time she has been alone in her room. She has left the facility once and that was to go to a doctor for an injection. When you don't have much life left, this is no way to spend it.
There is another reason to reopen and it has little to do with the numbers. It has to do with the people who no one seems to acknowledge, the people who have been laid off, fired, or whose businesses have been shut down. I'm retired and my pension arrives every month, so the shutdown has been an inconvenience. There are also people who have been furloughed but are still getting paid. But far more people have lost their livelihood, many with no job to go back to once the county reopens, yet the bills still come in and the family needs to be fed. It is cruel to keep them unemployed while those of us who are "inconvenienced" make the decisions. I have read comments from people wanting to see a hairdresser or barber, and they have gotten vilified for wanting such a unimportant service done. I, however, look at it from the other side, that of the barber or hairdresser. They are prevented from earning an income. Imagine you own a barber shop. Every month you have your rent to pay, your utilities, any loans on your business, plus all of your personal expenses (home mortgage, utilities, food, car payment, and on and on). You can't work because someone in the county health department, who is drawing a full paycheck doesn't think it is time to reopen the county.
Enough already. Reopen Alameda County. If you are concerned about your own risk, continue to shelter in place. Since I am 70, I won't be the first to join a Conga line, but don't destroy the financial lives of so many of our fellow citizens while we try to keep the virus at bay. Remember "flattening the curve" was not to prevent the virus from spreading, but rather slowing the spread to prevent the health care system from being overwhelmed. With only 4.33% of our hospital beds occupied by Covid patients, we have capacity in case there is a surge.
Parkside
on Jun 22, 2020 at 7:37 am
on Jun 22, 2020 at 7:37 am
didn't look safe at all in pleasanton.. hardly any mask, too close to each other.. etc etc. I liked the idea but the execution was poor.
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 22, 2020 at 8:57 am
on Jun 22, 2020 at 8:57 am
While it would be better if people did better about wearing masks, the Covid-19 infection rate in Pleasanton is 0.0874% (72 cases/82,372).[removed: commenter, please provide source] Near as I can find Valley Care has 167 beds which would make it 0.012% of capacity.
All Covid-19 data is from Alameda County Health Department. Population and capacity of Valley Care from Google. All data as of 8:55AM, 6/22/20.
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 22, 2020 at 10:01 am
on Jun 22, 2020 at 10:01 am
As additional perspective this article from the Sacramento Bee on April 13, 2020 <Web Link Covid-19 was the third largest cause of death in the state based on CDC data from April 2016, 2017 & 2018 averaged. On average heart disease took 1,202 and cancer 1,130 per week in April while 332 lives were lost the week ending April 11th. After publication the next two weeks saw a rise of 515 & 545 respectively and then remained around 500 for the rest of May. In June so far it has been below 440 per week.
Every life is precious regardless of how lost, but it is important to keep mind the relative comparison of things that happen normally.
Downtown
on Jun 23, 2020 at 1:00 pm
on Jun 23, 2020 at 1:00 pm
[removed - commenter, please provide source]
Pleasanton Meadows
on Jun 23, 2020 at 3:17 pm
on Jun 23, 2020 at 3:17 pm
Here's the source. I put it in the original post but it appears to have been stripped.
Web Link
In case it gets stripped again it is:
https www sacbee com news local health-and-medicine article241956956 html
with the appropriate : / and . in the correct places.
The number of deaths subsequent to the article is from the California Covid-19 Dashboard. The link is:
Web Link
In case it gets stripped it is:
https public tableau com views COVID-19PublicDashboard Covid-19Public
You have to go day by day on the graph and get the deaths and then add them up.