Yet another bike fatality | July 29, 2022 | Pleasanton Weekly | |

Pleasanton Weekly

Column - July 29, 2022

Yet another bike fatality

"She was a bit of laughter, and a bright light who had so much more to live for and so much more to give, and it was stolen because people with huge cars, huge trucks ... in this case they're no different from a drunk driver, but we treat the drunk drivers and people who have blind spots differently. They both took somebody's life because of their carelessness, because of their responsibility."

That's what Danville resident Mary O'Donnell told our reporter Jeanita Lyman last week during an interview about the death of her 40-year-old daughter Shawn O'Donnell, who died after being struck by a Mack truck while cycling to work in Washington, D.C., on July 20.

The story caught my eye in part because it happened in my old stomping grounds, although that area of Northwest D.C. was closer to George Washington University than up near my alma mater American University.

But more importantly, it was yet another case of a fatal crash that sure seemed preventable. The preliminary police report describes the truck as making a right turn even though the cyclist was riding in the roadway alongside.

I very much respect Mary O'Donnell's perspective ??" and the fact she was so open in an interview with us less than a day after such a personal tragedy. Hers is a fair opinion, and while I might go as far as to equate drunk drivers to unaware drivers, she was spot on to advocate for more consistent criminal consequences for avoidable collisions that claim lives. 

That could be an effective additional deterrent for fatal crashes (notice I don't say "accidents") across the board, whether involving just one car, multiple cars, a cyclist or a pedestrian/bystander. 

Individual civil, insurance or emotional repercussions often don't go far enough to influence societal change with such persistent problems. Or that's my takeaway at least, as we continue to see innocent victims lost to collisions where someone else is at fault. 

While most readers say law enforcement investigators and prosecutors should take a stronger stance on such crimes, and that may well be true in certain cases, the most impactful moves need to come at the legislative levels.  

The way the law is written seemed to be the deciding factor in the Tri-Valley's most prominent fatal cyclist collision last year. 

Career NFL assistant coach Greg Knapp, 58, died in the hospital five days after being hit while cycling on Dougherty Road in San Ramon on July 17, 2021 when a vehicle drifted into the bike lane and struck Knapp. 

Cycling advocates lambasted the lack of charges from the Contra Costa County District Attorney's Office against the driver, whose name was not released publicly, especially when police confirmed the driver was glancing at his hands-free cellphone in that fateful moment.

The key phrase there, under the law, being "hands-free." Although, there's a good argument to be made that prosecutors could have put the question to a jury instead of calling it on their own.

These are not easy decisions, and I don't mean to imply otherwise. There is often so much at play for prosecutors, beyond simply the facts of the case, in terms of achieving their ultimate goal: proving a crime beyond a reasonable doubt to earn a conviction.  

And what about when the facts aren't so black and white, for police and the DA? 

Recall the sad death of Christine Boyle cycling on Stanley Boulevard just across the Livermore border on Dec. 21, 2020 ??" she was one of five people killed in separate crashes in a 33-hour period then.

There was a situation where police actually first deemed 63-year-old Boyle at fault for riding off the sidewalk into the crosswalk without yielding to a turning gravel truck ??" a story I broke ??" only to rescind their finding weeks later after uproar from bike advocates. The trucker kept driving, later telling police he did not even know he hit someone. 

Livermore police quietly issued a press release soon afterward admitting to misinterpreting the local law around crosswalk cycling and all but clearing Boyle's name (without using it, interestingly). In the end, "a primary cause could not be found in this collision." 

So many of these bicycle fatalities are etched into my mind from my 12-year journalism career. It's important we don't forget them. That I don't forget.

One I'll always remember, because the case was solved but the driver is still on the lam, happened five months after I started with the Weekly. Alamo resident Dan Taylor, 72, was killed on an orchard-lined country road in Winters in Solano County while riding in a timed interval bicycle race on March 26, 2014.

The California Highway Patrol alleges the driver, Adrianna Melendez (now 31), took steps to conceal the crash and then fled when she learned investigators were looking for her. She is still at-large. The FBI has a "most wanted" reward out for her whereabouts that is still active, $10,000 for information leading to her arrest. 

It would be great to see the Taylor family get their day in court and hopefully a bit more closure. 

Editor's note: Jeremy Walsh has been the editor of the Embarcadero Media East Bay Division since February 2017. His "What a Week" column publishes on the second and fourth Fridays of the month.


Posted by Michael Austin
a resident of Pleasanton Meadows
on Jul 29, 2022 at 9:29 am

Michael Austin is a registered user.

Jeremy, I had a near death experience 30 years ago. A full-size sedan drove into bike lane, struck me, and run over me. During transport, EMT could not start IV due to extremities blood flow shut down and concentrated on internal core body injuries.

In the emergency room doctor after doctor explained my injuries. You have five or more broken ribs; we cannot count them all, they are too cylindrical on film. Another doctor, your left lung is collapsed, it looks like it is trying to inflate itself, we will monitor it, a tracheotomy may be necessary.

Another doctor, you have a bruised heart muscle, our concern is valve damage. The orthopedic returned, your right knee is dislocated, with tendon displacement.
Another doctor, your left kidney is lacerated. I will ask the intern to fit a catheter to monitor blood loss. I said I will pee on demand; I do not want a catheter.

The intern returned, he said, I did not want to do it either. Another doctor, you have concussion, he had my helmet in his hand, he pointed to fracture in my helmet. The helmet saved my life. Without it I would have fractured skull.

After multiple surgeries, a year in wheelchair, a titanium right knee. I was walking again unassisted. I am very fortunate.

Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.


Post a comment

In order to encourage respectful and thoughtful discussion, commenting on stories is available to those who are registered users. If you are already a registered user and the commenting form is not below, you need to log in. If you are not registered, you can do so here.

Please make sure your comments are truthful, on-topic and do not disrespect another poster. Don't be snarky or belittling. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

See our announcement about requiring registration for commenting.

Stay informed.

Get the day's top headlines from sent to your inbox in the Express newsletter.