News

Livermore upholds policy on flying commemorative flags at Civic Center

Council authorizes LGBT Pride flag display for remainder of June

The LGBT Pride commemorative rainbow flag flies at Livermore's Civic Center for the remainder of June. (Photo courtesy city of Livermore)

As LGBT Pride Month winds down, the rainbow flag can be seen flying at the Livermore Civic Center over the next several days.

At its June 13 regular meeting, the Livermore City Council upheld its existing policy around flying commemorative flags, which allows them to be displayed as a form of government speech.

The policy states that the mayor or a councilmember may request the display of a commemorative flag and then the council will consider the request at a formal public meeting.

At the May 23 regular council meeting, Councilmember Bob Carling requested to put a discussion to revisit the policy on a future agenda and to pause flying commemorative flags at the Civic Center until the discussion took place.

The Pride flag was not displayed at the Civic Center campus until after June 13.

Help sustain the local news you depend on.

Your contribution matters. Become a member today.

Join

A recent Supreme Court case originating in Boston served as a catalyst to the Livermore discussion, involving conservative activist Harold Shurtleff who was prohibited by the city of Boston from flying a Christian flag on a flagpole outside of city hall, despite the fact that the flagpole had been used to fly other groups' flags.

"The flagpole in question was located adjacent to a plaza that is a public forum, and the flagpole and a crank were made available to groups using the plaza to also raise and lower flags of their choosing for the duration of their event in the plaza," Livermore city attorney Jason Alcala wrote in a memorandum explaining the difference between Livermore's policy and Boston's.

The Supreme Court opinion concluded that the city of Boston did not make the raising and flying of flags by private groups a form of governmental expression, and that its policy and practice had created a public forum that prohibited Boston from refusing to allow the private group to fly a flag based upon viewpoint.

Alcala said during the meeting that because Livermore's policy already reserves the flying of commemorative flags strictly for government speech and does not allow private groups to raise their own flags, it is aligned with the Supreme Court's opinion.

"I was the one who brought this up and largely because we had received several emails from folks asking us about flying some other flags and I think they were confused -- I was confused -- about the decision of the Supreme Court and so my intention in asking for the discussion tonight was to get some clarity," Carling said.

He added that upon hearing from city staff and Alcala about the differences between the policies in Boston and Livermore he is "happy with our flag policy the way it stands."

After agreeing to uphold its current policy, the council voted unanimously to authorize flying the LGBT Pride flag for the remainder of June. A handful of public speakers shared their views on flying the Pride flag, the majority of which expressed their support for doing so.

The decision also carries a personal connection for two councilmembers, including Brittni Kiick who is an organizer with Livermore Pride and Vice Mayor Gina Bonanno whose late wife, Kimberly Cupps was born and raised in Livermore.

Referring to statistics from The Trevor Project and the Human Rights Campaign, Kiick said, "68% of LGBTQ youth report that they hear negative messages about their identity from their elected officials. Many say they hear nothing from their elected officials. I really want the children and youth and adults and elderly LGBTQ members in Livermore to be part of the tiny 16% of individuals that say they hear positive messages about their identity from their elected officials."

A complete recording of the June 13 City Council meeting is available here.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

Looking for more Livermore stories? The Livermore Vine will be your new source of vital news and information. Sign up to be among the first to get our daily local news headlines sent to your inbox for free.

Cierra started her journalism career after college as an editorial intern with the Pleasanton Weekly in 2014. After pursuing opportunities in digital and broadcast media and attending graduate school at Syracuse University, she’s back as the editor of the Vine. Read more >>

Follow PleasantonWeekly.com and the Pleasanton Weekly on Twitter @pleasantonnews, Facebook and on Instagram @pleasantonweekly for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Your support is vital to us continuing to bring you city government news. Become a member today.

Livermore upholds policy on flying commemorative flags at Civic Center

Council authorizes LGBT Pride flag display for remainder of June

by / Pleasanton Weekly

Uploaded: Wed, Jun 22, 2022, 3:57 pm

As LGBT Pride Month winds down, the rainbow flag can be seen flying at the Livermore Civic Center over the next several days.

At its June 13 regular meeting, the Livermore City Council upheld its existing policy around flying commemorative flags, which allows them to be displayed as a form of government speech.

The policy states that the mayor or a councilmember may request the display of a commemorative flag and then the council will consider the request at a formal public meeting.

At the May 23 regular council meeting, Councilmember Bob Carling requested to put a discussion to revisit the policy on a future agenda and to pause flying commemorative flags at the Civic Center until the discussion took place.

The Pride flag was not displayed at the Civic Center campus until after June 13.

A recent Supreme Court case originating in Boston served as a catalyst to the Livermore discussion, involving conservative activist Harold Shurtleff who was prohibited by the city of Boston from flying a Christian flag on a flagpole outside of city hall, despite the fact that the flagpole had been used to fly other groups' flags.

"The flagpole in question was located adjacent to a plaza that is a public forum, and the flagpole and a crank were made available to groups using the plaza to also raise and lower flags of their choosing for the duration of their event in the plaza," Livermore city attorney Jason Alcala wrote in a memorandum explaining the difference between Livermore's policy and Boston's.

The Supreme Court opinion concluded that the city of Boston did not make the raising and flying of flags by private groups a form of governmental expression, and that its policy and practice had created a public forum that prohibited Boston from refusing to allow the private group to fly a flag based upon viewpoint.

Alcala said during the meeting that because Livermore's policy already reserves the flying of commemorative flags strictly for government speech and does not allow private groups to raise their own flags, it is aligned with the Supreme Court's opinion.

"I was the one who brought this up and largely because we had received several emails from folks asking us about flying some other flags and I think they were confused -- I was confused -- about the decision of the Supreme Court and so my intention in asking for the discussion tonight was to get some clarity," Carling said.

He added that upon hearing from city staff and Alcala about the differences between the policies in Boston and Livermore he is "happy with our flag policy the way it stands."

After agreeing to uphold its current policy, the council voted unanimously to authorize flying the LGBT Pride flag for the remainder of June. A handful of public speakers shared their views on flying the Pride flag, the majority of which expressed their support for doing so.

The decision also carries a personal connection for two councilmembers, including Brittni Kiick who is an organizer with Livermore Pride and Vice Mayor Gina Bonanno whose late wife, Kimberly Cupps was born and raised in Livermore.

Referring to statistics from The Trevor Project and the Human Rights Campaign, Kiick said, "68% of LGBTQ youth report that they hear negative messages about their identity from their elected officials. Many say they hear nothing from their elected officials. I really want the children and youth and adults and elderly LGBTQ members in Livermore to be part of the tiny 16% of individuals that say they hear positive messages about their identity from their elected officials."

A complete recording of the June 13 City Council meeting is available here.

Comments

Pton Resident
Registered user
Foothill High School
on Jun 23, 2022 at 11:13 am
Pton Resident, Foothill High School
Registered user
on Jun 23, 2022 at 11:13 am

"Alcala said during the meeting that because Livermore's policy already reserves the flying of commemorative flags strictly for government speech and does not allow private groups to raise their own flags."

Perhaps Alcala is not aware that government is the people. We are the government. We fund the government with our taxes. Without us, there would be no government. So government speech is the speech of the taxpayers. I support gay rights 100 percent, but I do not think any government should be flying the flag of any specific group or cause. I sure as heck someone pushes back on this. Maybe an NRA flag, anti-guns, pro-choice, pro-life, Christian, Satan worshipping, thin blue line cop flag, defund the cops, NAMBLA. Livermore and every city and gov't entity would be wise to stay out of the virtue-signaling business and stick to running their cities/agencies.


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

In order to encourage respectful and thoughtful discussion, commenting on stories is available to those who are registered users. If you are already a registered user and the commenting form is not below, you need to log in. If you are not registered, you can do so here.

Please make sure your comments are truthful, on-topic and do not disrespect another poster. Don't be snarky or belittling. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

See our announcement about requiring registration for commenting.