Thanksgivukkah a rare event

Jews to enjoy Thanksgiving with lights of menorah

It hasn't happened since 1918 and it's not scheduled to occur again until 2070.

This year, American Jewry will enjoy their Thanksgiving dinner adorned with the lights of their Hanukkah menorah marking a historic convergence of Hanukkah and Thanksgiving.

While the Jewish calendar is slightly shorter than its Gregorian counterpart, rarely does it linger so far behind as to offer us a November flavored Hanukkah. So let's welcome Thanksgivukkah.

Of course interesting dinner combinations for the evening are already flurrying across the Web. The traditional Hanukkah fried dishes of potato latkes (pancakes) and jelly doughnuts might get a slight makeover this year and turn into sweet potato latkes and cranberry-sauce-filled deep fried pastries.

Yet more than cute culinary opportunities, there is in fact a deep and profound common thread that weaves these two holidays together.

In 167 BCE the Seleucid Greeks defiled the holy Temple in Jerusalem and brutally sought to crush the Jewish spirit and eradicate religious observance. In their effort to smother the flame of Judaism, the Greeks tampered the seals on all the flasks of olive oil used to kindle the Temple's candelabra (the Menorah) rendering them spiritually unfit for use. A small group of Jews called the Maccabees would not allow the Jewish spirit to be extinguished and, against all odds, they triumphantly overcame this oppression.

Upon rededicating the Temple, the Maccabees unearthed one lone flask of undefiled oil, enough to burn only one day. Miraculously this one flask burned brightly for eight days until new, pure olive oil was produced.

As taught in the Talmud, the ancient compendium of Jewish wisdom, the following year an eight day holiday was enacted. Culled from the Hebrew word "to dedicate", Hanukkah was established as a time for every Jewish home to kindle a menorah and uniquely designated as an occasion to recite prayers of "praise and thanksgiving" to God Almighty.

Almost 1800 years later another group of individuals seeking to escape religious persecution and in search of religious freedom journeyed across the Atlantic Ocean.

In 1789 President George Washington proclaimed Thursday the 26th of November a day of "public thanksgiving and prayer to be observed by acknowledging with grateful hearts the many signal favors of Almighty God" and devoted to "the service of that great and glorious Being who is the beneficent Author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be - that we may then all unite in rendering unto Him our sincere and humble thanks".

This year, two arduous journeys to overcome religious persecution and two stories wherein spiritual strength and light defied brute force and darkness; two holidays established to thank the Almighty for the bounty He bestows upon us will coincide.

How fitting. In this spirit let us appreciate and take full advantage of the freedoms this great country affords us; the freedom to live with the deepest sense of purpose and commitment to God and the freedom to act morally with goodness and kindness and create a Godlier universe.

Rabbi Raleigh Resnick is the director of Chabad of the Tri Valley, a Pleasanton-based Jewish center for life, community outreach, prayer, and education (founded 2005). He can be reached at


Like this comment
Posted by deborah
a resident of Ruby Hill
on Nov 26, 2013 at 8:54 am

Wow, Rabbi Raleigh. Thanks so much for making that connection. It makes perfect sense! Your words are meaningful and profound and I enjoyed reading them, and the message they send. I also noticed, reading between the lines, that there is absolutely nothing in the story of Hanukkah that has anything to do with giving expensive gifts that are wrapped in pretty boxes and tied with a bow. It is just my opinion, although I suspect you will agree, that the gifts we give on Hanukkah (and this year on Thanksgiving as well), should be in the form of moral, peace-promoting actions, and doing good, kind deeds that help to better the world in which we all coexist. Happy Thanksgivukkah to you and yours, and Mazel Tov about your brand new baby girl!

Posted by Name hidden
a resident of Ridgeview Commons

on Jun 6, 2017 at 9:31 am

Due to repeated violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are automatically removed. Why?

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Salami, Salami … Baloney
By Tom Cushing | 25 comments | 571 views

Time for new collaboration between city and school district
By Tim Hunt | 2 comments | 452 views