Brentwood, Dublin lead in commission's report on quality roadways

Pleasanton, Livermore close behind but with more miles of streets

The quality of the pavement on an average street or road in the Bay Area has improved slightly in recent years, but the struggle to find funding for necessary repairs will likely hinder further improvements, according to a report just released by a regional transportation agency.

The report, released by the Metropolitan Transportation Commission for the years 2006-2009, is based on a 100-point rating system of pavement conditions. The report showed that the overall average score for the Bay Area rose a single point compared to the previous report for 2005-2007 and remained in "fair" condition.

MTC spokesman John Goodwin said "while the numbers are inching in the right direction, we are far short of where we want to be as a region."

The report rated Brentwood, located in eastern Contra Costa County, as the city with the best streets in the Bay Area.

Besides Brentwood, which leads the MTC's "very good" list with an 85-point ranking, Dublin roads also ranked near the top with an 80-point rating, the highest of all Alameda County cities.

The other top leaders among Alameda County municipalities are Livermore, with 78 points, and Pleasanton, with 76 points. Union City and Emeryville also scored 76 points each, but with far fewer miles of roadway.

According to the survey, Livermore has 639 miles of streets, Pleasanton has 498 miles, Union City has 330, and Emeryville trails with just 47 miles of roadway.

The MTC study showed that Brentwood has 379 miles of roadway, with Dublin's roadways totaling just 228 miles.

Suisun City, located in Solano County, had the most improved rating compared to the agency's previous report for the time period between 2005 and 2007.

Los Altos, in Santa Clara County, was deemed the city with the best all-around pavement management program because of its consistently high ratings in recent years.

Goodwin said some cities that were at or near the top of the list were newly incorporated, like Brentwood, or very small like Belvedere, which finished with the fourth-highest rating.

However, Goodwin said the strongest indicator among cities and counties with good ratings was the portion of its budget spent on preventative measures, such as fixing cracks or other problems before they require major repairs.

"The dollar not spent on preventative repairs becomes five dollars you'll spend on rehabilitation," he said.

The lowest-rated streets in the Bay Area were in unincorporated Sonoma County, according to the report.

Goodwin said some of the factors for the low rating were the large network in Sonoma County, and the amount of rainfall the county gets compared to other parts of the Bay Area.

He said Sonoma County also did not have a dedicated transportation sales tax until recently, so as more money comes in from the tax, "we'll start to see some dividends in upcoming reports."

Transportation funding remains an issue for all cities and counties in the Bay Area, according to Goodwin.

MTC officials gave out $122 million in federal stimulus money to cities and counties in the region, but most aspects of Bay Area transportation, from state highways, to streets and roads and public transportation, remain underfunded, Goodwin said.

"Every part of the Bay Area transit system has more needs than there are resources available," he said.

He said MTC's policy has been to use any available money "to take care of what we already have" and "hold the line against further deterioration."

The entire list of ratings for Bay Area cities and counties is available at

Dan McMenamin of Bay City News contributed to this report.

We can't do it without you.
Support local journalism.


Like this comment
Posted by Gunslinger
a resident of Danville
on Feb 1, 2010 at 7:10 am

We'd have plenty of money to spend on our infrastructure, which is truly a matter of life and death, if California wasn't spending $20 billion a year on just two things- excessive teachers for small class sizes which are certainly not as important as safety, and of course illegal immigrants who, unlike legal immigrants are a net fiscal drain of $10 billion a year just to our state. There's also a million forms of welfare that go too far and when cut could save the state from structural collapse, but our politicians and the special interests spend like drunken sailors

thank you for doing a report on infrastructure

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Be the first to know

Get the latest headlines sent straight to your inbox every day.

Couples: "When Good People Have Affairs" by Mira Kirshenbaum
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 2,176 views