Post a New Topic
Original post made
on May 21, 2009
Excellent essay. Many won't understand it. Some of us do. Others do, but will ignore the message, or put down the messenger.
Hmmmm, Cholo's comment says it all. LOL!
Why are so many of you afraid to touch this subject?
We're not afraid - it is for the same reason that we don't need a sign in our front yard or a pep rally to vote No on G. We live our convictions every day and I don't think it will help to "pick a fight" with anyone on this blog.
Ms. Wortham's piece was masterful.
She speaks in grand measure what many of us think quietly.
Amy, thanks so much for this post. It was absolutely comforting to have someone so aptly put to words our emotions.
My point was not to pick a fight, just to get people talking. There are too many of us quietly seeing our once great nation change into something the we may not recognize over the next eight years.
Well the reason I cannot comment on it is for some reason I cannot get to the link as it gets picked up by the internet police here at work. What are the contents of the article?
We need to be careful as in 8 years the way our government is taking away our civil liberties we may not even have the right to vote. The way things are going our next best hope is to take back our government in next years elections. Whoever is up for election who is an incumbant I am voting out.
I just read this article and think it's beautifully written; however, there are some flaws in the argument she's making:
1) She claims that she is not conscious of race; However, she makes the assumption that everyone who voted for Obama - black or white - was motivated by race in that decision. I think many people voted for Obama as a referendum on the Bush Administration, which has very little to do with race and more to do with disatisfaction with the status quo at the time (remember that the economy started to unravel in Oct/Nov under Bush, not Obama).
2) She asserts that Obama = end of capitalism. The insinuation is that he has an agenda to turn us into a socialist or communist country. Yes, he has an agenda for socialized medicine and has had to take on a more activist role in the economy as a result of the bank failures, etc. but he's no Karl Marx. I don't think that private property or the ability to become an entrepreneur are going to vanish because of Obama.
Finally, I find it interesting that the author belongs to the Hoover Institution. The Republican presidents of the 1920s (Harding, Coolidge and Hoover), like many current Republicans, believed in lasseiz faire capitalism. Know what happened as a result of that? No government regulation of the stock market, over speculation, and the Great Depression! Adam Smith's invisible hand did not take into consideration the fact that unchecked greed eats the economy from the inside out. There needs to be government oversight... and there needs to be a middle class or no one buys the products those capitalists are making! In that sense, economic prosperity does come from the bottom up.
I know I'll get flamed, called a raging liberal, and told I don't understand. I understand the situation very well, as I've studied these subjects for the last 15 years. I am also not particularly liberal. I just think the author's stance is rather myopic.
She is NOT Black or African American.
At the bottom of the posters comments is a weblink, in case you missed it. Click on that. If not, I will cut and paste the text here...
No He Can't" by author Anne Wortham
Anne Wortham wrote the following article ten days after the election of Barack Obama. I have put her brief bio at the end.
"No, He Can't"
By Anne Wortham | Published 11/14/2008
Please know: I am black; I grew up in the segregated South. I did not vote for Barack Obama; I wrote in Ron Paul's name as my choice for president. Most importantly, I am not race conscious. I do not require a black president to know that I am a person of worth, and that life is worth living. I do not require a black president to love the ideal of America.
I cannot join you in your celebration. I feel no elation. There is no smile on my face. I am not jumping with joy. There are no tears of triumph in my eyes. For such emotions and behavior to come from me, I would have to deny all that I know about the requirements of human flourishing and survivalall that I know about the history of the United States of America, all that I know about American race relations, and all that I know about Barack Obama as a politician.
I would have to deny the nature of the "change" that Obama asserts has come to America. Most importantly, I would have to abnegate my certain understanding that you have chosen to sprint down the road to serfdom that we have been on for over a century. I would have to pretend that individual liberty has no value for the success of a human life. I would have to evade your rejection of the slender reed of capitalism on which your success and mine depend.
I would have to think it somehow rational that 94 percent of the 12 million blacks in this country voted for a man because he looks like them (that blacks are permitted to play the race card), and that they were joined by self-declared "progressive" whites who voted for him because he doesn't look like them. I would have to wipe my mind clean of all that I know about the kind of people who have advised and taught Barack Obama and will fill posts in his administrationpolitical intellectuals like my former colleagues at the Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government.
I would have to believe that "fairness" is equivalent of justice. I would have to believe that man who asks me to "go forward in a new spirit of service, in a new service of sacrifice" is speaking in my interest. I would have to accept the premise of a man that economic prosperity comes from the "bottom up," and who arrogantly believes that he can will it into existence by the use of government force. I would have to admire a man who thinks the standard of living of the masses can be improved by destroying the most productive and the generators of wealth.
Finally, Americans, I would have to erase from my consciousness the scene of 125,000 screaming, crying, cheering people in Grant Park, Chicago, irrationally chanting "Yes We Can!" Finally, I would have to wipe all memory of all the times I have heard politicians, pundits, journalists, editorialists, bloggers, and intellectuals declare that capitalism is deadand no one, including especially Alan Greenspan, objected to their assumption that the particular version of the anti-capitalistic mentality that they want to replace with their own version of anti-capitalism is anything remotely equivalent to capitalism.
So you have made history, Americans. You and your children have elected a black man to the office of the president of the United States, the wounded giant of the world. The battle between John Wayne and Jane Fonda is overand that Fonda won. Eugene McCarthy and George McGovern must be very happy men. Jimmie Carter, too. And the Kennedys have at last gotten their Kennedy look-a-like.
The self-righteous welfare statists in the suburbs can feel warm moments of satisfaction for having elected a black person. So, toast yourselves: 60s countercultural radicals, 80s yuppies and 90s bourgeois bohemians. Toast yourselves, Black America. Shout your glee, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Duke, Stanford, and Berkeley. You have elected not an individual who is qualified to be president, but a black man who, like the pragmatist Franklin Roosevelt, promises to"Do Something!" You now have someone who has picked up the baton of Lyndon Johnson's Great Society. But you have also foolishly traded your freedom and minewhat little there is leftfor the chance to feel good. There is nothing in me that can share your happy obliviousness
Anne Wortham bio;
Anne Wortham is Black, an Associate Professor of Sociology at Illinois State University and continuing Visiting Scholar at Stanford University 's Hoover Institution. She is a member of the American Sociological Association and the American Philosophical Association. She has been a John M. Olin Foundation Faculty Fellow, and honored as a Distinguished Alumni of the Year by the National Association for Equal Opportunity in Higher Education. In fall 1988 she was one of a select group of intellectuals who were featured in Bill Moyer's television series, "A World of Ideas." The transcript of her conversation with Moyers has been published in his book, A World of Ideas. Dr. Wortham is author of The Other Side of Racism: A Philosophical Study of Black Race Consciousness which analyzes how race consciousness is transformed into political strategies and policy issues. She has published numerous articles on the implications of individual rights for civil rights policy, and is currently writing a book on theories of social and cultural marginality. Recently, she has published articles on the significance of multiculturalism and Afrocentrism in education, the politics of victimization and the social and political impact of political correctness. Shortly after an interview in 2004 she was awarded tenure.
I think you spell it, "Whoa". BTW, would you like to be referred to as "a white"?
I am not 'less free' since Obama became president.
This guy is an inexperienced disaster and we all know it. The sad part is that I was dumb enough to vote for him and I fear my freedom.
Look at the white folk, gathered round the black, educated Republican. Watch them stare and point. They didn't know such a thing existed in their little white world. "Whoa, lookie that! Is it real? Someone poke it!"
Sorry, she is NOT black, negro, or African American. She is dark skinned but she is not what one generally thinks of as African American. In other words, she can pass as black.
Wow, Cholo, thank you for your insightful views...did you know that was your "outside" voice?
Tom...please don't call yourself dumb. We all make mistakes. Voting for Obama was indeed a big mistake...but count yourself in with the rest of us that have fallen for an infomercial and when they got the equipment, it didn't work as advertised.
Granted, an infomercial mistake doesn't usually cost us TRILLIONS, but hey, let's get this train back on track in November 2012! :)
Are you the kind of person that likes to collect injustices? Hmmmmmmm...?
If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.
Post a comment
Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online.
Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information
We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.
Select your neighborhood or school community: *
- Amador Estates
- Amberwood/Wood Meadows
- Another Pleasanton neighborhood
- Apperson Ridge
- Beratlis Place
- Bonde Ranch
- Bordeaux Estates
- Bridle Creek
- California Reflections
- California Somerset
- Canyon Creek
- Canyon Meadows
- Canyon Oaks
- Carlton Oaks
- Carriage Gardens
- Castlewood Heights
- Charter Oaks
- Civic Square
- Country Fair
- Danbury Park
- Deer Oaks/Twelve Oaks
- Del Prado
- Foothill Farms
- Foothill Knolls
- Foothill Place
- Foxborough Estates
- Golden Eagle
- Grey Eagle Estates
- Hacienda Gardens
- Happy Valley
- Heritage Oaks
- Heritage Valley
- Highland Oaks
- Jensen Tract
- Kolb Ranch Estates
- Kottinger Ranch
- Laguna Oaks
- Laguna Vista
- Las Positas
- Las Positas Garden Homes
- Lemoine Ranch
- Lund Ranch II
- Mariposa Ranch
- Mission Park
- Mohr Park
- Nolan Farms
- Oak Hill
- Oak Tree Acres
- Old Towne
- Pheasant Ridge
- Pleasanton Heights
- Pleasanton Meadows
- Pleasanton Valley
- Pleasanton Village
- Remen Tract
- Ridgeview Commons
- Ruby Hill
- Southeast Pleasanton
- Spotorno Ranch
- Stoneridge Orchards
- Stoneridge Park
- Sycamore Heights
- Sycamore Place
- The Knolls
- Val Vista
- Valley Trails
- Vineyard Avenue
- Vineyard Hills
- Vintage Hills Elementary School
- Walnut Hills
- West of Foothill
- Willow West
- Alisal Elementary School
- Amador Valley High School
- Donlon Elementary School
- Fairlands Elementary School
- Foothill High School
- Hart Middle School
- Harvest Park Middle School
- Horizon High School
- Lydiksen Elementary School
- Mohr Elementary School
- Pleasanton Middle School
- Valley View Elementary School
- Village High School
- Vintage Hills Elementary School
- Walnut Grove Elementary School
- another community
- San Ramon
Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.
By Roz Rogoff | 17 comments | 1,000 views
A Pope that a Unitarian Can Love – Part One of a Series
By Tom Cushing | 13 comments | 727 views
Reaching too far, again
By Tim Hunt | 2 comments | 343 views
Home & Real Estate
Send News Tips
Circulation & Delivery
San Ramon Express
© 2013 Pleasanton Weekly
All rights reserved.